Incomplete contact information — a missing email, a missing phone number, a name recorded wrong years ago — rarely looks like a problem. There's no error message, no dramatic failure. It's a quiet tax on every campaign, every appeal, and every "thank you" that never reaches the person it was meant for. Industry research on donor and constituent data gives a clearer picture of what that quiet tax actually costs, and what a complete record is worth once it's fixed.
What missing data costs in revenue
The starting number is bigger than most organizations expect. The Blackbaud Institute's 2024 Untapped Potential research found that, on average, 53% of records in a nonprofit's database are missing an email address — meaning more than half of a community can't be reached through one of the lowest-cost channels available at all.
What happens when that gap is closed is documented, not theoretical. In a data-quality case study reported by Experian UK, Australian nonprofit Caritas Australia saw active donors in its database rise 5%, and donations generated from direct-marketing campaigns rise 76%, after a clean-up of its contact records.
The same pattern holds outside the nonprofit sector. McKinsey's research on personalization found that companies growing fastest draw 40% more of their revenue from personalization than their slower-growing peers — and personalization is only possible when an organization actually knows who it's talking to.
What a complete record means for engagement and satisfaction
Donors notice the difference, and they say so. In Nonprofit Tech for Good's Global Trends in Giving research, 92% of donors in the US and Canada said nonprofits must invest in digital communication to stay relevant — something only possible with a working email address or phone number on file.
Salesforce's State of the Connected Customer research puts a number on the gap this closes: 73% of people expect an organization to understand their needs, but only 51% feel that it actually does. A complete, accurate record is what narrows that gap.
The clearest evidence may be the simplest: people an organization can actually stay in touch with, stay engaged. A 2025 Blackbaud Institute and GivingTuesday report found that donors an organization could reliably track and re-contact gave again at a 65% rate, compared with 52% for donors overall — a direct link between staying reachable and staying supported.
Beyond revenue — the other costs of an incomplete record
Revenue is the headline, but it isn't the whole picture. Validity's 2025 State of CRM Data Management report found that 44% of organizations estimate they lose more than 10% of annual revenue to poor-quality data in their systems — a cost that shows up in wasted outreach as much as missed opportunity.
- Wasted spend: every bounced email, undelivered letter, or disconnected phone number is a touch paid for and never received.
- Lower risk: an outdated or guessed contact detail is a common source of compliance exposure; a verified, enriched record avoids it.
- Staff time back: clean, complete records mean less manual look-up and fewer dead ends — more time spent on the relationship, not the record.
- Sharper reporting: funders and boards trust numbers built on records that are actually complete.
None of this requires new donors or a bigger list. It requires the list an organization already has to be complete.
This is exactly the gap Extensia's Community Contact Data Enrichment closes.
Extensia fills in missing names, email addresses, and phone numbers already sitting incomplete in your constituent records — so the outreach you're already paying for actually reaches the people it's meant for.
Request a Demo →Sources: Blackbaud Institute, Untapped Potential (2024) · Experian UK, data-quality case study on Caritas Australia · Nonprofit Tech for Good, Global Trends in Giving Report (2020) · McKinsey, "The value of getting personalization right—or wrong—is multiplying" (2021) · Salesforce, State of the Connected Customer · Blackbaud Institute & GivingTuesday report (2025) · Validity, State of CRM Data Management (2025). Figures are third-party industry research, cited for context; Extensia does not independently verify external studies.